Immaculate

 

Immaculate

2024

Director- Michael Mohan

Cast- Sydney Sweeney, Álvaro Morte, Benedetta Porcaroli, Dora Romano, Giorgio Colangeli, Simona Tabasco

            Sister Cecilia (Sidney Sweeney) is a young nun who has just arrived at a convent in Italy. The convent serves as a hospice and retirement home for older nuns, many that are close to death or who have developed dementia. The younger nuns, like Cecilia, take care of their elderly Sisters in their twilight years.

            After a short time in the convent, Cecilia becomes sick and it becomes quickly apparent that she is pregnant. After a rudimentary examination, her pregnancy is proclaimed a miracle, an Immaculate Conception. Cecilia is immediately placed in a position of reverence among the other sisters but the miracle begins to seem sinister and Cecilia starts to wonder what horrible thing has truly happened to her.

            The movie mixes equal parts religious trauma with body horror. Cecilia is quickly reduced to an unimportant object whose only value is in giving birth, regardless of her own desires or the dangers. Also, despite being in an environment surrounded by women, she finds herself at the mercy of men, as the Father, the Cardinal and the convent’s male doctor have complete say as to what happens to her.

Isolation, dogma, and hierarchy are used along with psychological gaslighting to create confusion and dread. The viewer knows that the truth, whatever it is, won’t bring relief.

            The film’s budget, though comparatively large by independent standards ($ 9 million) is still rather small by Hollywood standards. The film, which languished in development Hell for years, was saved by Sweeney’s recent Hollywood success. She had auditioned for the role years ago, and then ultimately became one of the film’s producers helping to finally get it off the ground, which makes this a bit of a passion project for her.

            It’s a very American film but has visible roots in Italian horror. First there is the location, with principal photography taking place in Rome and much of the dialogue being in Italian. The film further shows its love of Italian horror with a prominent use of Bruno Nicholai’s “Servizio fotografico” from the giallo, The Red Queen Kills Seven Times. There isn’t a lot of gore in the film, but what there is, is very graphic and Fulciesque with people’s faces being obliterated in a way that would have seemed natural in one of Lucio Fulci’s films. Also, though the film is not a gothic horror, it has a gothic aesthetic. Sweeney, walking through the darkened convent corridors with only a candle to guide her, clothed only in a thin white gown, looks very much the part of a gothic heroine.

            The film is a competent horror movie that most horror fans will find enjoyable, at least for one view. However, the story unambiguously deals with the very modern issue of reproductive rights, and there will be a few people who will identify very much with the protagonist’s struggle. I can easily see Sweeney’s nun taking her place alongside Florence Pugh’s Dani from Midsommar or Mia Goth’s Pearl, at least for the people who will identify closely with her.